Do I need a marketing strategy or just better tracking?

It’s a familiar scenario – you’re doing all this marketing, feeling busy and productive with it, but you’re unsure if it’s working. So, you do a bit of research and start looking at your marketing stats. Create a dashboard and before you know it, you’ve gone down a rabbit hole and are wondering whether those ‘people’ who have visited your web page from the Himalayas are really interested in what you’re offering. The key question is, is the issue missing strategy or missing tracking?

Which usually leads to another question. What is marketing strategy anyway, and how is it different from simply tracking what you’re doing?

What is marketing strategy and what does it actually give you?

What is marketing strategy really? Because you hear this buzz phrase a lot and aren’t really sure how it applies to your business.

Marketing strategies that work have these core elements:

  • Where you should put your focus
  • Who your ideal clients are
  • What action you want them to take
  • What tactics you should use

What a marketing strategy does is to prevent random acts of marketing!

Simple marketing plan laid out on sticky notes
Direction before action.

What better tracking solves

There are numerous ways you can track your marketing – find out more about those here:

Tracking isn’t all about the direction you should take (although it helps decide this). It’s about looking at:

  • What’s happened
  • Trends and patterns that might have occurred
  • Potential leaks in your marketing funnel

But when you’re tracking without a marketing strategy, you’re just collecting numbers and you’ll find yourself asking ‘so what?’ a lot.

Website analytics dashboard showing visitor data
Tracking shows what happened.

The common trap: tracking without strategy

With all the monitoring of data, you can get swept along looking at tools and data. Tracking becomes a comfort blanket. It’s something you do regularly.

Fancy dashboards which look impressive, but there’s no way to know what to change. And the more numbers you see the more overwhelmed you become, because there’s no direction to help make a decision.

The other wobble: strategy without tracking

You’ve got a fabulous strategy and you’re actioning it as planned. Then never measure the progress. There’s loads of effort going in, but confidence is pretty low as there’s no idea whether what you’re doing is working. When strategy has no feedback look it’s hard to know what to keep doing and what to stop.

How to tell which you need first: strategy or tracking?

Here’s some guidance to know which you should prioritise:

  • If you feel unclear on your priorities, then that’s a classic case of needing a strategy
  • If you know what you’re doing but can’t see the results, you need to start monitoring
  • If you are doing lots of marketing ‘stuff’ but unsure why, then strategy first.
  • If you have a plan but no idea what’s working, then that’s where tracking comes in.

If this has you nodding along, you’ll like the quick check in I’ve made. It helps you see whether your marketing is pulling its weight in under 10 minutes.

Strategy and tracking working together

So there is a sweet spot in all of this, as strategy and tracking go hand in hand. You’ll find that marketing strategies that work with monitoring:

  • Set the direction
  • Check progress
  • Build confidence
  • Remove the need for guesswork
  • Help with intentional decisions
Two joined cogs.
Strategy and tracking work best together.

Is your marketing pulling its weight?

As a business owner, figuring this all out alone is hard. You’re not a marketer – you’re a specialist in your own field.

If you’d like a quick way to sense-check whether your marketing is doing its job or just making you more overwhelmed, I’ve put together a free download. It’ll give you a clear view of what’s helping and what needs your attention.

Is your marketing pulling its weight? PDF being viewed on a Phone screen
A quick check-in for busy business owners.

Author

  • I’m Gill Bishop - a Chartered Marketer and Fellow of the Chartered Institute of Marketing. For more than 20 years I’ve been helping food, drink and lifestyle brands figure out how to get noticed, win with retailers and actually sell more stuff.

    Through my business, CherryAid Marketing, I work with everyone from kitchen table start ups, to established manufacturers. Some need a clear marketing strategy, others a category plan that makes sense to retailers, and plenty just want a sounding board who’ll keep them on track (and occasionally nag them into action)!

    I spend a lot of time in supermarkets, spotting what’s working (and what isn’t), pulling out insights and turning them into opportunities for clients. The Chartered Marketer and Fellow badges mean I’ve done the graft to back up the advice, not just years of experience but industry standards too.

    When I’m not working on client projects, you’ll usually find me writing blogs, recording my podcast, or wandering the aisles with my phone out taking photos of products.

    Connect with me on LinkedIn

    Follow me on Instagram

    Watch my YouTube videos

    View all posts